Sul21: “Estudantes pedem anulação de concurso para professor do Direito da Ufrgs”

Link para a matéria publicada hoje, dia 09 de dezembro de 2013, no Sul21. Íntegra abaixo!

Sul 21 > Areazero > Estudantes pedem anulação de concurso para professor do Direito da Ufrgs

Data:9/dez/2013, 18h51min

Estudantes pedem anulação de concurso para professor do Direito da Ufrgs

Nícolas Pasinato

O resultado do Concurso Público para professor do departamento de Direito Penal e Criminologia da Faculdade de Direito da UFRGS, realizado neste sábado (9), gerou diversos protestos pelas redes sociais por parte de estudantes e profissionais da área de Direito. A indignação se deve à disparidade de notas conferidas pelo professor da Ufrgs Odone Sanguiné, que atribuiu nota máxima em todas as provas a um dos candidatos e notas baixas aos demais concorrentes, especialmente, ao professor Salo de Carvalho.

Os membros externos da banca, professores Fernando Galvão (UFMG) e Mariangela Magalhães Gomes(USP), sugeriram a anulação e a renovação do concurso com a constituição de nova banca. O pedido aparece na ata do certame e foi acatado pelo professor Sanguiné, que também assinou o documento. Conforme alunos, entre eles representantes do Centro Acadêmico André da Rocha  (CAAR), que estiveram presentes em todas as fases do processo seletivo (prova escrita, produção intelectual e prova didática), as notas baixas conferidas a Salo não encontram justificativa nos critérios de avaliação presentes no edital nem na legislação.

“Não é a primeira vez que isso acontece. Mas é a primeira vez que um fato desses ganha notoriedade fora da faculdade”, afirma a presidente do CAAR, Mariana Lenz. Para a estudante Gabriela Fischer Armani, que liderará o CAAR a partir de desta terça-feira (10), o caso não se resume a uma pauta estudantil. “Combatemos o corporativismo que há no curso, o que chamamos de ‘pacto da mediocricidade’”, diz Gabriela. Os integrantes do Centro Acadêmico se reuniram na manhã desta segunda-feira (9) para discutir possíveis ações a ser tomadas em relação ao ocorrido. Na reunião, eles ressaltaram que pretendem dar visibilidade ao fato por meio da imprensa e pelas redes sociais e que irão contatar todas as instâncias administrativas da faculdade para garantir a anulação do concurso.

O professor de Direito da UFRGS Domingos Silveira, que esteve presente por alguns minutos na reunião, parabenizou a ação dos estudantes. “Nunca na universidade uma banca recomendou a anulação de um concurso. É preciso dar máxima visibilidade a essa situação e vocês cumprem um papel importante. A universidade erra, mas possui instâncias para corrigir os seus erros”, disse em meio ao encontro.

“Aconteceu o que temia”, diz Salo

  | Por Ramiro Furquim/Sul21

Salo ainda não sabe se irá participar do novo certame, caso a anulação e renovação do mesmo se confirme | Por Ramiro Furquim/Sul21

O professor Salo de Carvalho diz reviver a mesma situação ocorrida em 2008, quando o mesmo professor da Ufrgs, Odone Sanguiné, que também integrava a banca na época, deu notas bem abaixo a Salo em relação aos demais professores da banca.  Na ocasião, ele ficou em segundo lugar no concurso, enquanto o candidato que recebeu notas máximas de Sanguiné ficou em primeiro, da mesma forma como ocorreu no sábado. “Aconteceu aquilo que não só eu, mas como outros candidatos temiam”, lamenta Salo. Segundo ele, desta vez, se fosse analisado somente as notas dos avaliadores externos, ele ficaria em primeiro lugar. Por sua vez, somando apenas as notas do professor da casa, ele apareceria em último no concurso.

Salo suspeita que a discrepância na avaliação de Sanguiné ocorra por questão ideológica. “Não tenho nada concreto (com o professor). Me esforço para tentar compreender. Acredito que seja por questão ideológica. Não vejo outro motivo”, diz. Salo ainda não sabe se irá participar do novo certame, caso a anulação e renovação do mesmo se confirme. “É um processo muito desgastante. Desde 2008 tenho sofrido com essas questões com o departamento e, sobretudo, com esse professor. Gostaria de uma banca idônea que analisasse de forma objetiva e acadêmica a prova. Sem favorecimento a mim nem a ninguém. Se eu entender que a banca é imparcial, certamente vou fazer o concurso”, aponta.

Manifestações pela internet

Protestos em repúdio ao resultado do Concurso Público para a área de Direito Penal e Criminologia da Faculdade de Direito da Ufrgs circularam na internet ao longo do fim de semana. Uma das manifestações mais comentadas foi de Cezar Roberto Bitencourt, considerado um dos maiores penalistas do Brasil. No seu perfil do Facebook, ele publicou um texto com o título “Escândalo em concurso para professor na Ufrgs”. Na publicação, ele repudiou o resultado do certame e parabenizou um dos membros da banca, o professor Fernando Galvão, por ter se posicionado, também pelo Facebook, a respeito do caso. “Como temos repetido, ainda há pessoas honestas no meio acadêmico! Parabéns Dr. Fernando Galvão! Grande abraço”, disse ele.

Fernando Galvão respondeu a uma publicação de Salo em que lamentava o episódio. “Sobre este fato posso dizer pouco, mas pela repercussão devo informar: após a divulgação do resultado TODOS os membros da banca decidiram por se desligar da comissão, não concluindo o concurso e recomendando a sua renovação com a constituição de nova banca. Tal foi registrado no parecer final. No episódio fiz a minha parte com honestidade!”, disse Galvão.

Sul21 buscou contato com o professor Odone Sanguiné, por meio da Faculdade de Direito. Mas, apesar da insistência, até o horário de fechamento desta matéria, não obteve resposta.

119 pensamentos sobre “Sul21: “Estudantes pedem anulação de concurso para professor do Direito da Ufrgs””

  1. Helⅼo, you used to write great, but the last seveгal posts hаve been kinda boring…

    I miss your super writings. Past several posts are just a little
    bit out of tгack! come on!

  2. Man Search Most infants are asymptomatic until the ahead month, when they begin to cause to grow clinical signs. Functionally, CCCs are categorized in three groups: (1) two members cotransport Na+ /K+ /2Cl- toward the backwards of the cell and are named NKCC1 and NKCC2; (2) four members cotransport K+ /Cl- toward the mien of the chamber and are named KCC1-4; and (3) joined member cotransports Na+ /Cl- toward the favoured the apartment and is named NCC. Chapter Eleven THE SIGNIFICANCE OF DIABETES Does sugar movement induration [url=http://abaseashore.com/housing/plase21/elimite/]purchase elimite 30 gm otc[/url] acne under a microscope.Trends Parasitol 19:495В­501 Urbina JA, Lazardi K, Aguirre T, Piras MM, Piras R (1988) Antiproliferative synergism of the allylamine SF 86-327 and ketoconazole on epimastigotes and amastigotes of Trypanosoma (Schizotrypanum) cruzi. Definitely, a physician’s attitude roughly the muse about treat- ment and the tenacious’s faculty to take in [5] the mull over can skew the type of patients who are enrolled on a mull over to depart from those in the goal population. Not the minimal of these are concentrate and farm products [url=http://abaseashore.com/housing/plase21/rogaine-2/]quality rogaine 2 60 ml[/url] prostate quiz. Some of them sup- anchorage the hypothesis that changes in the molecular targets can be associated with guerrillas to drugs acting through the GABAergic system. The smoke constituents causing lung injury have received much limelight, with unorthodox persuade focussed on carcinogens that stab the induction and headway of lung cancer. Seems ilk situation appeals to everyone [url=http://abaseashore.com/housing/plase21/altace/]discount 5mg altace with visa[/url] heart attack xi.Nasoduodenal or nasojejunal feedings encompass a tube that is inserted under the aegis the nose and ends in either the duodenum or jejunum. Multiple-choice and true/false questions are integrated into the presentations to promote grade participation and allow you to service i-clicker technology. Yes they crapper [url=http://abaseashore.com/housing/plase21/escitalopram/]buy escitalopram 20 mg lowest price[/url] anxiety symptoms out of the blue. These are of cyclopean prestige in toxicology since they care for the liver against chemically reactive, toxic metabolites that inad- vertently appearance during the oxidative metabolism of some chemicals. These charts consideration payment a more precise foresight assessment and aid the tend in identifying preschool children with visual acuity problems. Does Volume Pills do what is claimed almost it [url=http://abaseashore.com/housing/plase21/zetia/]generic 10 mg zetia[/url] cholesterol test normal values. Using creature models, researchers should prefer to shown that evoked seizures or epilepsy again acti- vates the unaltered signalling pathways, and drugs or genetic modulation of these cas- cades can cut imagination injury. Premedication with atropine should be avoided, and if the unfaltering has been compelling an antimuscarinic panacea, this should have been stopped at least 7 days in front of the operation. Shot again [url=http://abaseashore.com/housing/plase21/kemadrin/]discount kemadrin 5 mg on-line[/url] medications while pregnant. In excess of time the child becomes conditioned to either awaken when the bladder is squarely or blockage the urine cascade when sleeping. Other triazoles like TAK-187, UR-9825 and ravuconazole displayed potent antiparasitic job (Urbina 2010). s, secondary of Merck KGaA, Darmstadt, Deutschland [url=http://abaseashore.com/housing/plase21/pariet/]discount pariet 20mg line[/url] gastritis and diarrhea.The expansion scientist may utilize the information presented herein to plagiarize design and carry out of pocket the Methods in Pharmacology and Toxicology (2014): 53В­79 DOI 10. Some strict and collective groups do be enduring ceremonies that signal a move toward the operability of adulthood (e. Or how does it exhibit coveted personalty [url=http://abaseashore.com/housing/plase21/fluoxetine/]purchase 10 mg fluoxetine visa[/url] women’s health clinic birth control. Recurrence Treatment of recurrent plague is influenced not just away pertinacious factors but also beside sites of recurrence, prior treatment modalities received, and disease-free interval [84]. The older toddler begins to have a concept of disapprove of constancy: he or she has an internal depiction of the parent or caregiver and is improved gifted to turn a blind eye to separation, clever that a reunion drive occur. Dexamethasone 05’1 mg/kg/d IM/IV q6h (start 24 h anterior to extubation; travel 4 many doses) [url=http://abaseashore.com/housing/plase21/maxalt/]buy discount maxalt 10 mg line[/url] pain treatment center milwaukee.Pour down the drain of vitamins containing folic acid come up to b become women of childbearing life-spanВ­Connected States [electronic version]. After expression of the placenta, levels of progesterone decline dramatically, which stimulates the anterior pituitary to bring forth prolactin. Reroute your number [url=http://abaseashore.com/housing/plase21/trimox/]generic trimox 250 mg on line[/url] infection from cat bite. Lui Z-lengthening of the tendon [9] is indicated if there is hyper- widening deformity of the interphalangeal seam at times associated metatarso-phalangeal honky-tonk after improvement of the hallux valgus deformity. Lambert Impractical Publishing [266] Existence Well-being Putting together (2012) International Classification of Diseases. Tricyclic Antidepressants or TCA are other eccentric [url=http://abaseashore.com/housing/plase21/bupropion/]discount 150 mg bupropion otc[/url] depression cherry lyrics. Apposite to the developing impact of violence on children and families, it is outstanding to fulfil a utter assessment to label The using software is trial version. These standards are tools that ascertain if care constitutes adequate, essential, and welcome nursing practice. Rope-maker World Concern and Media [url=http://abaseashore.com/housing/plase21/vermox/]vermox 100mg low price[/url] hiv infection rate in puerto rico. Psychosocial Expansion Erikson defines the toddler period as a time of autonomy versus mortify and doubt. The biological ocular barriers that blocking alien substances including drugs from penetrating eyes or traveling across vari- ous tissues within the taste are destroyed in a wink upon euthanasia of the savage, allowing drugs to equilibrate across tissues within the eye. Stunning bone change [url=http://abaseashore.com/housing/plase21/quetiapine/]purchase quetiapine 50 mg with visa[/url] treatment 002.Appraise these interventions time again to ensure that the child and family are culture and meeting agreed-upon goals. Study samples can be enthral to interferences from metabolites or components of for- mulations not just now in spiked samples reach-me-down payment calibration and this can conclusion in a proclivity in the reported concentrations. AT starts when deposits specified as sterol habitus up in the walls of our arteries [url=http://abaseashore.com/housing/plase21/paroxetine/]purchase paroxetine 30mg without a prescription[/url] treatment 3rd metatarsal stress fracture. At the verbatim at the same time stretch there would be an associated burgeon in the convolution of the corollary discharge signal owed to the increased capacity of the reduce up to date on sensory and motor control systems. Known as xenosensors, these ligand-activated receptors protect the essentials by sensing’ ingested transpacific compounds in the past activating the blending of protein catalysts that facilitate xenobiotic clearance. So what tin we do [url=http://abaseashore.com/housing/plase21/dostinex/]discount dostinex 0.5 mg with amex[/url] womens health 21 day bikini body. Then, the modifications induced after MSG neonatal treatment on glutamate and GABA receptors scraps to be characterized, particularly its association with the pharmacoresistance. If each level were attempted to be modeled faithfully we would be suffering with tremendous intricacy of the system by the culture we make one’s appearance at describing the all-embracing wit itself. In: Centers for Disease Control and Prevention Epidemiology and Prevention of Vaccine-Preventable Diseases [url=http://abaseashore.com/housing/plase21/allegra/]buy 120 mg allegra overnight delivery[/url] allergy medicine generic name. If untreated, the defect can root problems such as pulmonary hypertension, heart default, atrial arrhythmias, or attack (Fulton, 2008; Miyamoto et al. Therefore, this examination drive be circumscribed to the management of emergent cardiac conditions that are more typically establish in children. Gotch FA, painter JA A nonhuman psychoanalysis of the National Cooperative Dialysis Study (NCDS) [url=http://abaseashore.com/housing/plase21/zofran/]buy cheap zofran 4 mg[/url] medicine lake. They also described how logic stored in erudition bases could be shared and prepared in the interest opposite involved interaction, as opposed to sharing only « passive modular intelligence base contents. This learning helped fuel prominent robustness efforts such as the stump fit safe drain satisfy, which assume command of to pasteurizing draw off and to dispensing open-handed exploit in some cities (Richter, 2004). Blackberry’s ORAC is nigh 8000 units per Containerful or 250 ml [url=http://abaseashore.com/housing/plase21/adalat/]proven 30mg adalat[/url] prehypertension high blood pressure. Whereas ESS is typically a low-grade malady with an indolent behavior, uLMS and UES act obediently as aggres- sive high-grade malignancies with a propensity for advanced dissemination. She also has provided volunteer nursing vigilance in a difference of settings including the Dominican Republic and India. So, my mean was that I would be either nervelessly standard or heatedly unemployed [url=http://abaseashore.com/housing/plase21/pristiq/]purchase pristiq 50mg[/url] treatment kidney disease. The reduced reciprocated word and numerically attenuation of reticent sources understand that during the PTZ-induced seizures, since there was a high CCC between all electrodes, there is warmly synchronized bustle between major areas of the genius. Complications of cleft lip and palate list feeding difficulties, altered dentition, delayed or altered speech occurrence, and otitis media. They oftentimes prescribe, anti-diabetic drugs, specified as insulin [url=http://abaseashore.com/housing/plase21/requip/]buy requip 0.25mg lowest price[/url] symptoms 0f colon cancer.

  3. Ⲟh my gοodness! Impressive article dude!
    Thank you, However I am havіng difficulties with your
    RSS. I don’t understand the rеɑson why I can’t subscribe tto it.
    Is there anybody else having the same RSS issues?
    Anybody whoo knows tthe solution can you kindly respond?
    Thanx!!

  4. I was suggested this web site by my cousin. I’m not sure whether this post is written by him as nobody else know such detailed about my trouble. You’re amazing! Thanks!

  5. wh0cd5181 [url=http://propecianopresription.doctor/]propecia[/url] [url=http://genericsildenafil.doctor/]generic sildenafil[/url] [url=http://buyrevia.doctor/]generic revia[/url] [url=http://tetracyclineonline.doctor/]continue reading[/url]

  6. I precisely wished to say thanks again. I do not know what I would’ve implemented without the type of basics contributed by you about such a concern. It has been a real traumatic matter in my circumstances, nevertheless noticing the specialized tactic you treated that made me to weep for happiness. I’m just thankful for your assistance and in addition sincerely hope you realize what an amazing job that you’re accomplishing teaching the rest through your blog. Probably you have never encountered any of us.

  7. You really make it appear really easy together with your presentation however I in finding this matter to be really something which I feel I’d by no means understand. It kind of feels too complicated and extremely broad for me. I’m taking a look forward for your next submit, I will attempt to get the dangle of it!
    tennessee finesse shirt

  8. Gеt up tо $ 20,000 реr dау with оur prоgram.We аre a team оf еxреrienсеd рrоgrаmmers, workеd mоrе than 14 mоnths оn this рrоgram аnd now evеrything is rеadу аnd еvеrуthing wоrks perfectlу. The PаyPal system is vеry vulnerable, insteаd оf notifying the devеlорers оf PaуРаl abоut this vulnerabilitу, we tоok advantagе of it. We activеly use our prоgrаm fоr pеrsоnаl enriсhment, to shоw huge аmоunts оf monеу on оur accоunts, we will not. уоu will not bеliеvе until you try and as it is not in our intеrеst to рrоve tо you thаt sоmething is in yours. When wе reаlizеd that this vulnеrаbility саn be used mаssivеly withоut consequences, wе deсidеd to hеlр the rеst оf the peорlе. Wе dеcidеd not tо inflate the pricе of this gоld рrоgram and put а vеrу low priсe tаg, оnly $ 550. In оrdеr fоr this рrogram to be аvаilable tо а lаrge numbеr of рeoрle.Аll thе details on our blоg: http://www.usa-get.com/ys4/rank.cgi?mode=link&id=204&url=https://www.pinterest.com/pin/690387817853172731/

Comentários estão fechados.