-
torpor : lack of response to
normal or ordinary
stimuli
-
obnubilation / clouding of consciousness / mental fog
/ obtundation
: a lowered level of consciousness with reduced ability to
respond properly
to external stimuli.
-
coma vigil / "typhoid state" / locked-in
syndrome / agrypnodal coma / de-efferented state /
pseudocoma : no
stimulus can recall the patient to awake
Aetiology :
Symptoms & signs : fever, delirium
,
quadriplegia,
mutism, intact consciousness, preservation of voluntary vertical
eye movements
and blinking, subsultus tendinum (the twitching of
fingers and wrists),
carphologia
(picking at bedclothes), and floccillation (picking at
imaginary
objects).
-
I or precoma : the
neuropsychiatric
state preceding coma, as in hepatic encephalopathy,
characterized by stupor : a
lowered level
of consciousness manifested by the subject's responding only
to continuous
vigorous stimulation; swallowing and respiratory rate are
preserved; sphincters
are no longer controlled
-
benign stupor : a
condition of inattentiveness,
inaction, and unresponsiveness from which recovery is
likely; the term
is often used to denote such symptoms occurring in the
depressive phase
of bipolar disorder, although it is now recognized that this
condition
has a poor prognosis and is more correctly termed a malignant
stupor.
-
catatonic stupor : the extreme decrease in reactivity
to the environment
and in spontaneous activity characteristic of catatonic
schizophrenia.
-
epileptic or postconvulsive stupor : stupor following
an epileptic
convulsion
-
idiopathic
recurrent
stupor (IRS) / endozepine stupor

-
II or properly
said coma
:
no answers to stimuli, impaired oral swallowing, pupillar
reflex is preserved
-
III or deep coma :
pharyngeal
swallowing, pupillary, corneal and tendineal
reflexes are all impaired, Babinski's
sign
-
IV / irreversible
coma /
brain or cerebral death / coma depassé :
irreversible
and definitive cessation of all encephalic functions
(including those associated
with brainstem), as manifested by absolute unresponsiveness to
all stimuli,
absence of all spontaneous muscle activity, including
respiration, shivering,
etc., and an isoelectric EEG
for 30' (amplitude < 2 mV for
> 12 hours),
all in the absence of hypothermia
or intoxication by CNS depressants. There are systematic
changes in gene
expression in postmortem human brains associated with tissue
pH and terminal
medical conditionsref
: those who suffered prolonged deaths over hours or days, such
as by multi-organ
failure or coma, showed one type of genetic profile (during a
prolonged
illness, the brain might be starved of oxygen and sugars,
triggering it
to switch on a whole suite of genes that help cells survive
and to dampen
down genes involved in energy metabolism, perhaps because the
cells are
deprived of essential nutrients. Patients who suffered a
prolonged death
also seem to have more acidic brain tissue due to acidic
by-products of
anaerobic metabolism, such as lactic acid : brain death
probably occurs
when the pH threshold is crossed). Those who died suddenly
from a heart
attack, accident or suicide showed another. Recent findings
corroborate
potential harm to the patient during testing and reiterate the
importance
of preoxygenation, in duction of normocapnia before
assessment, and assurance
that the oxygen catheter is smaller than the diameter of the
endotracheal
tube (if that method is used).4–7 The intention of all
approaches is to
safely allow predetermined levels of hypercapnia and acidosis
to develop
without induction of hypoxaemia or barotrauma. Absent
spontaneousbreathing
eff orts at this maximum physiological stimulus (usually,
partial pressure
of carbon dioxide in arterial blood >8·0 kPa) confi rms
loss of
medullary respiratory function.
In 1959, Mollaret and Goulonref
introduced the term coma dépassé (irreversible coma) in
describing
23 comatose patients who had lost consciousness, brain-stem
reflexes, and
respiration and whose electroencephalograms were flat. In 1968,
an ad hoc
committee at Harvard Medical School reexamined the definition of
brain
death and defined irreversible coma, or brain death, as
unresponsiveness
and lack of receptivity, the absence of movement and breathing,
the absence
of brain-stem reflexes, and coma whose cause has been identifiedref.
In 1971, Mohandas and Chouref
described damage to the brain stem as a critical component of
severe brain
damage. The Conference of Medical Royal Colleges and their
Faculties in
the United Kingdomref
published a statement on the diagnosis of brain death in 1976 in
which
brain death was defined as complete, irreversible loss of
brain-stem function.
This statement provided guidelines that included a refinement of
apnea
testing and pointed to the brain stem as the center of brain
function:
without it, no life exists. In 1981, the President's Commission
for the
Study of Ethical Problems in Medicine and Biomedical and
Behavioral Research
published its guidelines (President's Commission for the Study
of Ethical
Problems in Medicine and Biomedical and Behavioral Research.
Defining death:
a report on the medical, legal and ethical issues in the
determination
of death. Washington, D.C.: Government Printing Office, 1981).
This document
recommended the use of confirmatory tests to reduce the duration
of the
requisite period of observation but recommended a period of 24
hours for
patients with anoxic damage, and it made the ruling out of shock
a requirement
for a determination of brain death. More recently, the American
Academy
of Neurology conducted an evidence-based review and suggested
practice
measures. This report specifically addressed the tools of
clinical examination
and the validity of confirmatory tests and provided a practical
description
of apnea testingref.
The clinical neurologic examination remains the standard for the
determination
of brain death and has been adopted by most countries. The
clinical examination
of patients who are presumed to be brain dead must be performed
with precisionref1,
ref2.
The declaration of brain death requires not only a series of
careful neurologic
tests but also the establishment of the cause of coma, the
ascertainment
of irreversibility, the resolution of any misleading clinical
neurologic
signs, the recognition of possible confounding factors, the
interpretation
of the findings on neuroimaging, and the performance of any
confirmatory
laboratory tests that are deemed necessary. One may argue that
the decision
should be made by a neurologist or a neurosurgeon, but the
necessary degree
of expertise is not readily available in many smaller hospitals.
No data
suggest that a second assessment by a different physician
reduces error
or reduces the possibility of negligence. Nevertheless, there
are major
differences among countries in the requirements for the number
of observers,
the specialty of the assessing physician, the duration of
observation,
and the use of confirmatory testsref.
Neurologic examination to determine whether a patient is brain
dead
can proceed only if the following prerequisites are met: the
ruling out
of complicated medical conditions that may confound the clinical
assessment,
particularly severe electrolyte, acid–base, or endocrine
disturbances;
the absence of severe hypothermia, defined as a core temperature
of 32°C
or lower; hypotension; and the absence of evidence of drug
intoxication,
poisoning, or neuromuscular blocking agents.
Interpretation of the computed tomographic (CT) scan is
essential for
determining the cause of brain death. Usually, CT scanning
documents a
mass with brain herniation, multiple hemispheric lesions with
edema, or
edema alone. However, such a finding on the CT scan does not
obviate the
need for a careful search for confounders. Conversely, the CT
scan can
be normal in the early period after cardiorespiratory arrest and
in patients
with fulminant meningitis or encephalitis. Examination of the
cerebrospinal
fluid should reveal diagnostic findings in circumstances of
infection of
the central nervous system.
A complete clinical neurologic examination includes
documentation of
coma, the absence of brain-stem reflexes, and apnea. The
examination of
brain-stem reflexes (Figure 1) requires the measurement of
reflex pathways
in the mesencephalon, pons, and medulla oblongata. As brain
death occurs,
patients lose their reflexes in a rostral-to-caudal direction,
and the
medulla oblongata is the last part of the brain to cease to
function. Several
hours may be required for the destruction of the brain stem to
be complete,
and during that period, there may still be medullary functionref.
In the unusual circumstances of persistent functioning of the
medulla oblongata,
there is normal blood pressure, a cough response after tracheal
suctioning,
and tachycardia after the administration of 1 mg of atropine.
Table 1. Clinical Criteria for Brain Death in
Adults and
Children.
Figure 1. The Steps in a Clinical Examination to
Assess
Brain Death.
In step 1, the physician determines that there is no motor
response
and the eyes do not open when a painful stimulus is applied to
the supraorbital
nerve or nail bed. In step 2, a clinical assessment of
brain-stem reflexes
is undertaken. The tested cranial nerves are indicated by
Roman numerals;
the solid arrows represent afferent limbs, and the broken
arrows efferent
limbs. Depicted are the absence of grimacing or eye opening
with deep pressure
on both condyles at the level of the temporomandibular joint
(afferent
nerve V and efferent nerve VII), the absent corneal reflex
elicited by
touching the edge of the cornea (V and VII), the absent light
reflex (II
and III), the absent oculovestibular response toward the side
of the cold
stimulus provided by ice water (pen marks at the level of the
pupils can
be used as reference) (VIII and III and VI), and the absent
cough reflex
elicited through the introduction of a suction catheter deep
in the trachea
(IX and X). In step 3, the apnea test is performed; the
disconnection of
the ventilator and the use of apneic diffusion oxygenation
require precautionary
measures. The core temperature should be 36.5°C or higher, the
systolic
blood pressure should be 90 mm Hg or higher, and the fluid
balance should
be positive for six hours. After preoxygenation (the fraction
of inspired
oxygen should be 1.0 for 10 minutes), the ventilation rate
should be decreased.
The ventilator should be disconnected if the partial pressure
of arterial
oxygen reaches 200 mm Hg or higher and if the partial pressure
of arterial
carbon dioxide reaches 40 mm Hg or higher. The oxygen catheter
should be
at the carina (delivering oxygen at a rate of 6 liters per
minute). The
physician should observe the chest and the abdominal wall for
respiration
for 8 to 10 minutes and should monitor the patient for changes
in vital
functions. If there is a partial pressure of arterial carbon
dioxide >
60 mmHg or an increase > 20mm Hg from the normal base-line
value, apnea
is confirmed. ABP denotes arterial blood pressure, HR heart
rate, RESP
respirations, and SpO2 oxygen saturation measured by pulse
oximetry
The depth of coma is assessed by documentation of the
presence or absence
of motor responses to a standardized painful stimulus, such as
pressing
on the supraorbital nerve, temporomandibular joint, or nail
bed of a finger.
The examination should then proceed with the assessment of the
presence
or absence of brain-stem reflexes. If brain-stem reflexes are
absent, the
examination should document round or oval pupils in
midposition with respect
to dilatation (4 to 6 mm in diameter) with no response to
bright light.
No oculocephalic movements should be elicited by rapid turning
of the head;
however, it may be not only difficult to interpret the results
of this
test, but also problematic when there is a concomitant spinal
injury. The
absence of provoked eye movements must be confirmed by testing
with cold
caloric stimulation; the tympanum should be irrigated with ice
water after
the head has been tilted 30°. There should be no tonic
deviation toward
the cold stimulus. The presence of clotted blood or cerumen in
the ear
canals may diminish the response in a person who is not brain
dead. The
physician should test the corneal reflex by touching the edge
of the cornea
with a swab to produce an adequate stimulus. The cough
response can best
be assessed with bronchial suctioning; moving the endotracheal
tube back
and forth may not be an adequate stimulus.
After the absence of brain-stem reflexes has been documented,
apnea
must be formally tested. Apneic diffusion oxygenation is the
procedure
that is used most commonly to maintain oxygenation during
apnea testingref1,
ref2).
The
threshold of maximal stimulation of the respiratory centers in
the
medulla oblongata (which may be malfunctioning because of
damage) has been
arbitrarily set in the United States at a partial pressure of
arterial
carbon dioxide of 60 mm Hg or a value that is 20 mm Hg higher
than the
normal base-line value. Preoxygenation eliminates the stores
of respiratory
nitrogen and accelerates the transport of oxygen through an
oxygen catheter
in the trachea. The mechanical ventilator must be disconnected
in order
to obtain an appropriate assessment of breathing, because the
ventilator's
sensors may give false readingsref.
The increase in the partial pressure of carbon dioxide is
biphasic and
occurs at a rate of approximately 3 mm Hg per minute. This
method is simple
and usually free of complications, provided that adequate
precautions are
taken. If complications such as hypotension or cardiac
arrhythmia occur,
they may be due to a failure to provide an adequate source of
oxygen or
to a lack of preoxygenationref.
Very few data are available on patients who resume breathing
despite the
loss of all other brain-stem reflexes, but if breathing does
occur, it
does so early during the test and typically at a partial
pressure of arterial
carbon dioxide of about 40 mm Hg.15 No recent audits of the
competence
of physicians in determining brain death have been published,
but apnea
testing has often been conducted without adequate precautionsref.
The clinical examination to determine brain death in children
follows
the same principles as that in adults (Table 1)ref.
However, many children have hypothermia when they become
comatose after
a severe brain injury. Several of the cranial-nerve responses
are not fully
developed in preterm and full-term neonates, and it is
difficult to perform
a neurologic assessment in an infant who is in an incubator.
Because of
the limitations on the clinical examination of neonates, an
observation
period of 48 hours is recommended, as well as a confirmatory
test, such
as electroencephalography or a study of cerebral blood flowref.
The most controversial issue related to the determination of
brain
death is the occurrence of clinical signs that suggest some
retention of
brain functionref1,
ref2,
ref3,
ref4.
Even in the absence of motor responses, spontaneous body
movements may
be observed during the apnea test, while the body is being
prepared for
transport, at the time of an abdominal incision for the
retrieval of organs,
or in synchrony with the respirations produced by the
mechanical ventilatorref1,
ref2.
These body movements are generated by the spine, and the
evidence of brain
death in such cases comes from a consistent clinical
documentation of brain
death and confirmation by isoelectric electroencephalography
or cerebral
angiography. These slow body movements may even include a
brief attempt
of the body to flex at the waist, making it seem to rise. The
arms may
be raised independently or together. Forceful flexion of the
neck or rotation
of the body may initiate these movements. Legs seldom move
spontaneously,
although in two patients, "stepping movements" (an exaggerated
triple flexion)
were noted just before brain deathref.
Other manifestations that have been reported are a slow
turning of the
head to one side, an undulating toe sign (snapping the big toe
leads to
an undulating movement of the toes)ref,
facial twitchingref,
a persistent Babinski reflex, and tendon, abdominal, and
cremasteric reflexes.
Neurologic states that can mimic brain death : misdiagnosis of
brain
death is possible if a locked-in syndromeref,
hypothermiaref,
or drug intoxicationref1,
ref2,
(Goldfrank LR, Flomenbaum NE, Lewin NA, Weisman RS, Howland
MA, Hoffman
RS, eds. Goldfrank's toxicologic emergencies. 6th ed.
Stamford, Conn.:
Appleton & Lange, 1998) is not recognized. The
locked-in syndrome
is usually a consequence of the destruction of the base of the
pons. The
patient cannot move the limbs, grimace, or swallow, but the
upper rostral
mesencephalic structures involved in voluntary blinking and
vertical eye
movements remain intact. Consciousness persists because the
tegmentum,
with the reticular formation, is not affected. The condition
is most often
caused by an acute embolus to the basilar arteryref.
More dramatic is the reversible Guillain–Barré syndrome
involving
all the peripheral and cranial nerves. The progression occurs
over a period
of days, and knowledge of the history should prevent the
dangerous error
of diagnosing brain death (Kotsoris H, Schleifer L, Menken M,
Plum F. Total
locked-in state resembling brain death in polyneuropathy. Ann
Neurol 1984;16:150-150.abstract)
-
Accidental hypothermia from prolonged environmental exposure
may mimic
loss of brain function, but alcohol intoxication and head
injury are often
major confoundersref.
Hypothermia causes a downward spiral of loss of brain-stem
reflexes and
pupillary dilatation. The response to light is lost at core
temperatures
of 28°C to 32°C, and brain-stem reflexes disappear when the
core
temperature drops below 28°Cref.
These deficits are all potentially reversible, even after
extreme hypothermiaref.
-
The effects of many sedative and anesthetic agents can
closely mimic brain
death, but aspects of brain-stem function, particularly the
pupillary responses
to light, remain intact. When ingested in large quantities,
many drugs
can cause a partial loss of brain-stem reflexes. Formal
determinations
of brain death documenting conditions that are entirely
similar to those
caused by structural lesions are exceptional but have been
reported in
cases of intoxication with tricyclic antidepressants and
barbituratesref1,
ref2.
A more complex problem is the possible confounding of the
clinical determination
of brain death by metabolites or traces of circulating
pharmaceutical agents.
Screening tests for drugs may be helpful, but some toxins
(e.g., cyanide,
lithium, and fentanyl) may not be detected by routine
screening testsref.
A clinical diagnosis of brain death should be allowed if
drug levels (e.g.,
of barbiturates used to treat increased intracranial
pressure) are below
the therapeutic range. A reasonable approach is as follows:
If it is known
which drug or poison is present but the substance cannot be
quantified,
the patient should be observed for a period that is at least
four times
the elimination half-life of the substance, provided that
the elimination
of the drug is not interfered with by other drugs or organ
dysfunction.
If the particular drug is not known but high suspicion
persists, the patient
should be observed for 48 hours to determine whether a
change in brain-stem
reflexes occurs; if no change is observed, a confirmatory
test should be
performed.
Confirmatory tests are optional in adults but recommended in
children younger
than one year oldref.
In several European, Central and South American, and Asian
countries, confirmatory
testing is required by law. Certain countries (e.g., Sweden)
require only
cerebral angiography. In the United States, the choice of tests
is left
to the discretion of the physician, but bedside tests seem to be
preferred.
-
Cerebral angiography may document nonfilling of the
intracranial arteries
at the entry to the skull because the systolic pressure is
not high enough
to force blood through the intracranial vascular treeref.
Perivascular glial swelling and the formation of subintimal
blebs caused
by ischemia may cause the collapse of smaller vessels,
leading to increased
intravascular resistanceref.
Cerebral angiography is performed with an injection in the
aortic arch
to visualize both the anterior and the posterior
circulation. Arrest of
flow is found at the foramen magnum in the posterior
circulation and at
the petrosal portion of the carotid artery in the anterior
circulationref.
Magnetic resonance angiography may produce similar views.
-
Electroencephalography is used in many countries and remains
one of the
most well-validated confirmatory tests. Recordings are
obtained for at
least 30 minutes with a 16- or 18-channel instrument. In a
patient who
is brain dead, electrical activity is absent at levels
higher than 2 µV
with the instrument set at a sensitivity of 2 µV per
millimeter (Figure
2A)ref1,
ref2.
However, the high levels of sensitivity set on the
electroencephalography
machine increase artifacts, which are plentiful in the
intensive care unit
because of the presence of multiple devices.
Figure 2. Examples of Bedside Tests to Confirm Brain Death.
Panel A shows an isoelectric electroencephalogram in which the
only
pulse is artifactual. Shown is a bipolar montage with the
electrodes placed
according to 10/20 configuration. Transcranial Doppler
ultrasonograms show
reverberating flow (Panel B) and small systolic peaks (Panel
C), both of
which are patterns seen in patients with massively increased
intracranial
pressure that can also be seen when brain death has occurred.
In Panel
D, a dynamic nuclear scan shows no intracranial filling — the
so-called
hollow-skull sign.
-
transcranial doppler ultrasonography has a sensitivity of
91-99% and a
specificity of 100%ref.
A portable, 2-Hz, pulsed-wave Doppler ultrasonographic
instrument is used,
insonating both middle cerebral arteries and vertebral
arteries. The absence
of a signal may be artifactual if a bone window interferes
with insonation.
In patients who are brain dead, transcranial Doppler
ultrasonography typically
reveals the absence of the diastolic or reverberating flow
that is caused
by the contractive force of the arteries; the pulsatility
index is very
high, with systolic velocities that are only a fraction of
the normal level
(Figure 2B and Figure 2C)ref1,
ref2.
-
Nuclear imaging with technetium may demonstrate an absence
of intracerebral
uptake of the tracer (Figure 2D)ref.
The correlation with conventional angiography is good. The
diagnostic criteria
of the most commonly used confirmatory tests are described
more fully in
Table 2.
After the clinical criteria of brain death have been met, the
physician
should inform the next of kin, who can be approached about organ
donation
(Omnibus Reconciliation Act of 1986, 42, U.S.C. § 13206-8). The
physician
is required to abide by state law with respect to organ
donation. In the
United States, organ-procurement agencies must be notified to
request the
donation of organs. If the legal next of kin declines to donate
organs,
it is good medical judgment to discontinue mechanical
ventilation. When
mechanical ventilation and support are continued because of
ethical or
legal objections to their discontinuation, what usually follows
is an invariant
heart rate from a differentiated sinoatrial node, structural
myocardial
lesions leading to a marked reduction in the ejection fraction,
decreased
coronary perfusion, the need for increasing use of inotropic
drugs to maintain
blood pressure, and a fragile state that leads to cardiac arrest
within
days or weeksref.